Welcome to College Hill Arsenal
Beautiful Color Casehardened 1st Model Colt New Line Revolver in .38 Colt

Beautiful Color Casehardened 1st Model Colt New Line Revolver in .38 Colt

  • Product Code: FHG-2359-SOLD
  • Availability: Out Of Stock
  • $1.00

At the close of the American Civil War the Colt Patent Firearms Company was aware of two facts that would greatly impact their business practices for the next decade. First, the end of war not only meant no more major US military orders for handguns in the foreseeable future, but it also meant that thousands of surplus US military percussion revolvers would soon be flooding the market, making newly made percussion revolvers difficult (if not impossible) to sell. Second, the day of the percussion revolver was over, and the new self-contained cartridge handgun was the wave of the future. Unfortunately for Colt, Smith & Wesson held the exclusive rights to Rollin White’s patent on the bored-through cylinder, which meant that until that patent expired in 1869 there was no easy way for Colt to manufacture a traditional cartridge revolver without infringing upon that patent. The first of the Colt “bored through cylinder” cartridge revolvers to be offered in 1870, after the expiration of White’s patent, were not alterations of existing models, but were two completely new product lines, the .22RF Colt Open Top and Colt Cloverleaf House pocket revolvers. The Open Top series of arms continued the traditional Colt percussion revolver assembly practice of utilizing three basic parts to assemble the gun, the frame, barrel and cylinder. The Open Top, as the name implied had no top strap and the barrel was secured to the frame with a wedge as it had been with the percussion guns. The Cloverleaf House revolvers, however, utilized a solid frame and top strap with the barrel screwed into the front of the frame. This basic construction technique would become the standard for all future Colt revolver production. With the introduction of Colt’s iconic Model P, the 1873 Single Action Army revolver in 1873, it was clear that even though the Open Top and Cloverleaf House series had been rather successful (over 114,000 Open Tops were produced with between 1871 and 1877 and just under 10,000 Cloverleaf House revolvers were manufactured between 1871 and 1876), Colt needed to bring a new series of modern pocket pistols to market that included the various design advancements provided by the Single Action Army, and also to compete with Smith & Wesson, and the numerous cheaply made “Suicide Special” revolvers that were already available for those who were looking to purchase a pocket pistol for protection. 


The new series of Colt pocket revolvers was dubbed, ironically, the New Line series. These guns were designed by William Mason of Colt and were covered under US Patent Number 155,095. Mason was the man responsible for many of Colt’s early cartridge revolver designs and alterations. The solid frame New Line series was introduced in 1873 and was available in five frame sizes, dependent upon the five basic chamberings of the gun. The revolvers were actually available in eight different calibers, including .22RF, .30RF and .32, .38 and .41 calibers; either rimfire or centerfire. The guns had five shot cylinders and were available with barrels ranging from about 2 ¼” to 10” in length, with the shorter barrels tending to predominate as these were, after all, pocket revolvers. The revolvers were single action, spur trigger affairs, with bird’s head shaped grips to increase their concealability. The standard finish was nickel plating with high luster nitre blued hammer and trigger surfaces and screws. Blued barrels with nickeled frames were available as well as blued revolvers with color casehardened frame. Custom finishes including gold and silver washes were also options if the customer was willing to pay the price. Standard grips were two-piece varnished rosewood, but other exotic materials like ebony, mother of pearl and ivory were available for an extra charge as well. Interestingly, walnut, which had been the mainstay of Colt grips since the inception of the company, was rarely used on the New Line revolvers. 


Most of the New Line revolvers were produced in two models. The “First Model” had shorter cylinder flutes than the “Second Model” and the cylinder locking notches are located behind the flutes on the sides of the cylinder at the rear. The “Second Model” revolvers has much longer flutes, with the locking notches relocated to the rear face of the cylinder. One exception to this rule was the .30 Rimfire New Line revolver, which was only manufactured with the “Second Model” type cylinder, even though this revolver was only produced during the “First Model” period. Most models had their caliber or chambering acid etched onto the left side of the barrel, with the exception of the earliest production larger frame revolvers. As with most pocket pistols of the era, the .22 rimfire variant, with the smallest frame, was the most popular and some 55,343 were manufactured between 1873 and 1877. The .30 rimfire version, with the second smallest frame was only produced for three years, from 1874 to 1876, with some 10,946 being produced. The .32 caliber sized frame was produced from 1873 to 1884, with some 22,000 revolvers being produced in both rimfire and centerfire versions. The next-to largest frame size was chambered for .38 caliber (again in either rim or center fire) and was manufactured from 1874 to 1880 with about 5,500 being manufactured. The .38 caliber guns were serialized in the same range as the largest frame, .41 caliber guns. The .41 caliber revolvers were also available in either rim or center fire versions, with some 9,363 guns being produced between 1874 and 1879.  The total production of all frame sizes other than .22 was nearly 10,000 units fewer than the .22 caliber guns alone, attesting to the popularity of the smallest of the New Line family. In the end, it was Colt’s development of the 1877 series of double action revolvers in .32 Colt (Rainmaker), .38 Colt (Lighting) and .41 Colt (Thunderer) that brought production of the New Line revolvers to an end. The new small frame, double action revolvers were such an improvement over the single action spur trigger New Line guns, that the sales dropped of precipitously after the introduction of the 1877 revolvers. As the 1877s were available with short barrels for pocket carry, the customer who wanted a Colt for protection simply bought the new design. The other death knell for the New Line series was the continual influx of cheaply made “Suicide Special” pocket revolvers on the market. Colt simply could not compete price wise with these cheap and often unsafe handguns. As Colt was not willing to sacrifice quality in order to meet the price point of the competitors, they simply could not remain in that market and be economically viable.


Offered here is a FINE condition example of a rare blued and color casehardened, 1st Model Colt New Line .38 Colt Pocket Revolver. The New Line .38 revolvers had the next to largest of the New Line frames and was the frame size produced in the smallest quantity with only 5,500 produced during the production run, including both the centerfire .38 Colt and the .38 Rimfire chamberings. The revolver has the traditional Colt “acid etched” panel on the left side of the barrel that reads:




This legend allowed the same marking to be applied to either the rimfire or centerfire versions of the revolvers. As a first model, the revolver has the shorter cylinder flutes, with stop notches cut on the rear side of the cylinder, rather than the rear face. The top of the 2 ¼” long round barrel is clearly roll marked in two lines: 





The barrel address is bracketed by a pair of Maltese Crosses, one at each end. The four-digit serial number 1696 is stamped on the bottom of barrel, with the truncated number 696 found on the rear face of the cylinder between the chambers, on the left side of the frame under the grip and inside both of the bird’s head grips in period pencil. As noted above, the revolver is in about FINE condition. It retains about 20%+ of its original blued finish on the barrel and cylinder with about 75%+ vivid color case hardening on the frame. The barrel appears to have flaked, resulting in most of the finish loss with the cylinder experiencing a similar fate. One quarter of the cylinder shows mottled oxidized loss suggesting it was laying on fabric for a significant amount of time. The colors on the frame are really stunning and even the backstrap retains lovely color. The only area of significant loss is on the right side of the frame, where the colors have flaked and dulled, again indicative of having laid on fabric for a long time. The metal is almost entirely smooth and free of real significant pitting, although there is some scattered pinpricking present. There is also some scattered surface oxidation and flecks of oxidized surface scale are scattered on the frame and cylinder. All markings in the metal are crisp, sharp and fully legible. The top side of the hammer retains strong amounts of its original bright niter blued finish, with the sides showing a moderately oxidized, mottled brown and gray appearance. The niter blued trigger retains some traces of its original finish as well  but is has dulled and faded significantly and is no longer vibrant. The screws all retain strong traces of their niter blued finish as well, with some still quite vibrant and others duller and more faded. The nitre blued cylinder arbor pin retains much of its bright blue as well, with the balance a dusky bluish patina. It retains crisp and sharp knurling. The bore of the revolver is in about FINE overall condition and is mostly bright with crisp rifling, showing only some minor pinpricking and oxidation along its length with some light pitting near the muzzle. The original German silver front sight is in place on the barrel near the muzzle. The revolver is mechanically FINE and functions correctly on all positions. The revolver indexes, times and locks up exactly as it should. The two-piece rosewood grips are in FINE condition as well and as noted they are correctly numbered to the revolver. The grips are solid and complete and are free of any breaks, cracks or repairs. They retain about 70%+ of their original varnish, with most of the loss along the high edges and contact points. The grips show some minor surface scuffs and some light bumps and dings from carry, use and storage, but show no signs of abuse. 


Overall, this is a solid and crisp example of the next to largest and rarest frame size of the Colt New Line Revolvers. The gun is 100% complete, correct and original and retains the large majority of its original nickel finish. With only 5,500 of these powerful little revolvers manufactured over the six-year period form 1874-1879, it can be difficult to find these large bore pocket pistols. As most of the production was nickel plated, these stunning blued and case colored guns are even less often encountered. This is a very nice example that is worthy of being added to any nice collection of New Line Colt revolvers. This is one of those no excuses revolvers that displays very well and is a good value, as you can rarely purchase such a nice old west period Colt revolver for under $1,000, particularly in .38 Colt caliber and with this much attractive original finish. 


Write a review

Please login or register to review

Tags: Beautiful, Color, Casehardened, 1st, Model, Colt, New, Line, Revolver, in, .38 Colt